How Compassion and Accountability Can Coexist in Leadership
If you manage people or projects of any kind, you've likely experienced that moment of indecision when you had to choose how to handle a difficult situation. Maybe an employee wasn't performing at a high enough level, or maybe a team member was exhibiting not-quite-collaborative behavior. You wanted to be empathetic toward the person and help them improve, but you also had to oversee a project getting done. You were torn between the person and the project. You felt you had to choose between showing compassion or teaching accountability.
Thankfully, compassion and accountability can coexist at work. In fact, they need to both be present in order to cultivate an empowering and productive team environment where people feel both cared for and challenged.
Employees who work for compassionate managers feel 25% more engaged and are 11% less likely to burn out (Source). There is a clear link between an employee having a compassionate manager and a positive work experience. This is because we rely on our managers to help us manage our workload and our emotions at work. When we have a question, issue, or opportunity, we go to our managers and ask for advice. Our managers are responsible for advocating for us, reallocating resources to better suit our bandwidth, coaching us through new or difficult situations, and finding ways to help us grow. Good managers empower, challenge, and guide. If you have a good manager, you probably feel safe to try new things and make mistakes, excited to talk with them about new ideas, and confident you can deal with whatever might crop up at work. You've got someone in your corner, and that counts for something.
This is where compassionate leadership shines. Employees don't want to only be viewed as cogs in a machine. They want someone to recognize the humanity behind the work. Have you ever wished your boss would step away from a project for just a second and talk to you like a human being? When was the last time your boss asked you how you felt about something--not how the project was going? Check how often the subjects of your conversations are deliverables versus you as a person. When managers care about us as human beings, we feel validated and seen. We can feel both safe and brave. Comfortable and challenged. When someone acknowledges who you are and the unique value you bring to your work, you feel better about what you produce every day. Feeling valued goes a long, long way.
When someone acknowledges who you are and the unique value you bring to your work, you feel better about what you produce every day.
But does this mean the work itself suffers? Absolutely not. In fact, it's quite the contrary. When supported by compassionate managers, teams solve problems more effectively and recover from mistakes more quickly. Employees know their managers care about their wellbeing and want the best for them, so they tend to work harder to prove themselves to their manager and fulfill the optimism and confidence their manager has in them. Compassionate managers connect team members more openly and provide strategic information more frequently because they know their team members need collaboration and access to information in order to be successful; those team members, in turn, are better connected and informed.
Employees who report to more compassionate leaders also tend to receive more context when sorting through a tricky situation. If I'm your boss, and I care about you, I'm not just going to deliver bad information and let you struggle to sort through it. (Goodness--I would never.) I would give context. I would sit with you and talk through your thoughts. I would give you space to process things in a way that is tailored to your personal needs. I would nurture a safe environment where you could ask questions and admit how you're feeling. I would coach you through creating a plan for success moving forward. I would follow up with you a few days later and ask if you needed anything from me. I would find some resources that may help you and share them with you (with no expectations or pressure to use them). I would want to see you thrive.
A big part of compassion in leadership is the interest in seeing our team members thrive. Think of the opposite. A manager who you would never describe as compassionate probably acts cold toward his team members, only cares about results (and not processes), never asks you your feelings or opinions, never apologizes or admits mistakes, doesn't care to provide information or make connections, can be temperamental or downright aggressive at times...the list goes on. Is that what you pictured, too? I've encountered managers with all of these qualities, and I can assure you their team members were not chomping at the bit to talk to them, make them proud, or work with them at all. They were silently withering into their shells...while likely applying for jobs at other companies.
When you want to see your team members thrive, you have to hold them accountable. Growth is an essential part of any work experience. Even if you stay in the same job your entire career, you will learn new things, have new ideas, try new solutions, tackle new problems, meet new people who have new perspectives, and feel new ways, especially when the market takes new and unexpected turns. Newness brings opportunity for growth, and growth is impossible without accountability.
So what does accountability look like? Have the difficult conversation. Be honest. Point to specific situations, results, and obstacles. Provide timely feedback (in private). Watch for golden nuggets of progress, and measure--and celebrate--growth. Don't play favorites. Don't brush things under the rug. Don't make assumptions or excuses or justifications. Call things out. Be explicit and objective and clear. And make sure you always give context. Explain that you care. Explain why this matters. Explain what could be better as a result of some small change. Then help them get there. Tailor your approach to each individual person. Some people want to process things on their own; others like to talk things out. Some people want the blunt truth; others need a bit of softening before getting to the heart of the matter.
Nurture an environment where people are trusting and empathetic while also being clear and reliable.
Remember: Ignoring is allowing, and allowing is promoting. Your actions can enforce the behavior you want to see again or correct the behaviors that aren't serving your team well.
As you do this, little by little, you can cultivate a culture of accountability and compassion. You can nurture an environment where people are trusting and empathetic while also being clear and reliable. And you can start by modeling this yourself: Hold yourself accountable. Show that you are not perfect and prove to others how you act when you face adversity. Don't expect more of others than you would do yourself; it starts with you. Learn, model, then enforce.
And please, please, always lead with trust, integrity, and humanity.






Comments